Home Lawsuits Allegations of Price Fixing: The dkoldies Lawsuit and the Vintage Video Game...

Allegations of Price Fixing: The dkoldies Lawsuit and the Vintage Video Game Market

Dkoldies is an online video game store that buys, sells, and trades new and used video games, consoles, and accessories. In 2022, dkoldies faced a lawsuit over allegations of price manipulation in the secondhand video game market.

dkoldies Lawsuit

Background on dkoldies

Founded in 1999, dkoldies started out as a small business run out of founder Derrick Samuels’ home. Over the past two decades, it has grown into one of the largest online used video game stores. Dkoldies offers a huge selection of games and systems spanning from the Atari days up to modern consoles. It also buys used games from customers for resale on its site.

Details of the lawsuit against dkoldies

In January 2022, dkoldies was hit with a lawsuit filed in a Pennsylvania federal court by four individuals on behalf of all affected customers in the US. The class action lawsuit accused dkoldies of artificially inflating the prices on its platform to take advantage of the COVID-19 pandemic and limited supplies of popular used video games. The lawsuit alleges that dkoldies conspired with its suppliers to restrict availability and push up resale prices to unfair levels beyond actual market value. This violated federal and state consumer protection laws against unfair trade practices, according to the plaintiffs.

Reaction by dkoldies

Dkoldies swiftly defended itself against the allegations that it manipulated the vintage video game market. In an official statement, dkoldies asserted that it aims to provide fair value prices to buyers and sellers based on actual supply and demand. The online retailer also noted that it deals with over 11,000 transactions per month, demonstrating its efforts to serve customers ethically amid a chaotic secondhand games market. It described the lawsuit’s implications as “completely without merit.”

Impact on the used video game market

The dkoldies lawsuit has drawn increased scrutiny around reseller practices in the multibillion-dollar vintage video game market. Pressure has mounted for transparency and fair pricing as rare games continue surging in value. While dkoldies dismissed price manipulation accusations, the case highlighted debates around ethical implications with supply shortages, condition variances, and speculative spikes for in-demand retro games. For customers, the lawsuit underscored the importance of carefully assessing used game conditions, rarity, and real values across multiple resellers.

FAQs about the dkoldies lawsuit

What unfair practices does the lawsuit accuse dkoldies of?

The lawsuit accuses dkoldies of artificially inflating prices for used video games by restricting availability and conspiring with suppliers. This allegedly resulted in unfair prices beyond actual market value.

What was dkoldies’ response to the lawsuit?

Dkoldies firmly denied the lawsuit’s price manipulation allegations. It asserted that its prices reflect real supply and demand in a volatile used game market with over 11,000 monthly transactions.

What evidence did the lawsuit provide to back up the accusations?

The lawsuit did not cite specific evidence. It primarily argued dkoldies violated consumer laws through general unfair pricing practices.

What types of customers are part of the lawsuit?

The lawsuit proposed a class action suit representing all customers in the US affected by dkoldies’ alleged price inflation.

How could the lawsuit impact dkoldies as a company long-term?

If successful, the lawsuit could financially and reputationally damage dkoldies through penalties and brand harm. However, dkoldies claimed strong defenses, signaling a desire to fully contest accusations.

Does the lawsuit affect other used video game retailers besides dkoldies?

The lawsuit directly targets only dkoldies but brings wider scrutiny to potential unfair pricing issues in the used game retail industry.

What should used game buyers consider when assessing retailer prices?

Customers should compare prices across sellers, evaluate conditions, confirm rarity, and determine fair market value through price charting sites. This provides perspective beyond any single retailer’s potential bias.

Did dkoldies suffer any initial consequences from the lawsuit?

Beyond reputational impact, there have not been reports of specific repercussions faced by dkoldies thus far. As the case proceeds, more effects could unfold.

How could the lawsuit’s outcome set precedents for used game sales?

If dkoldies faces penalties, it may pressure retailers toward greater pricing transparency and fairer policies. A defeated lawsuit, however, gives implicit support to retailers’ current operations.

Where can I find updates on the status of the lawsuit against dkoldies?

As a federal class action suit, the case filings are public record accessible through the Pennsylvania federal court system’s online database known as PACER. Dkoldies may also give updates on its website.


The dkoldies lawsuit presents a turning point for customer trust and industry ethics in the volatile vintage gaming market. While dkoldies fervently opposed price manipulation accusations, legal consequences and brand scrutiny remain at stake. As the lawsuit plays out and the used game market continues evolving at breakneck speed, consumers and retailers alike will be compelled to re-examine practices in light of transparency, fairness, and good faith. This conversation echoes similar controversies already seen in 2023 around ethics in the online ticket resale industry, such as the recent bumble lawsuit. Ultimately, the goal across these secondary markets should focus on serving customers’ interests rather than exploiting supply constraints for unreasonable profits.

Related Articles :

The Little League Bunk Bed Lawsuit: Seeking Justice for Easton Oliverson
Federal Vaccine Mandate Lawsuit
The Ozempic Lawsuit: Navigating the Complexities of Pharmaceutical Litigation
Camp Lejeune Lawsuit Update

Parul is an experienced blogger, author and lawyer who also works as an SEO content writer, copywriter and social media enthusiast. She creates compelling legal content that engages readers and improves website visibility. Linkedin


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here